352: Anti-Hustle Marketing & Social Media Burnout | Cara Chace

You’re tired, you’re posting anyway, and you can’t tell if any of it is actually working. Social media can start to feel like a job on top of your job, and it’s hard to step off when everyone says consistency is the answer.

This week I’m chatting with Cara Chace, author, speaker and independent marketing strategist.

We talk about making your marketing intentional instead of default, what to do when you want to cut back but fear losing momentum, and how to look at your numbers without the FOMO.

If you LOVED this episode, make sure you share this on your Instagram stories and tag us @contentqueenmariah and @carachace.

⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠LEARN THE DETAILS OF A CONTENT STRATEGY WITH MY FREE AUDIO GUIDE⁠⁠⁠⁠

KEY EPISODE TAKEAWAYS 👇

✨ Intentional beats default. Know what you need from each platform before you show up, because the platforms already know exactly what they need from you.

✨ Look at your data before you decide

✨ Signposts, not stages. Keep your top two platforms working for you and set up the rest like a business card, so people can find you without you feeding the machine.

✨ You are allowed to change your mind

✨ Take your presence back

SHOW RESOURCES 👇

If you like this episode, don't forget to share it to your Instagram stories and tag me⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ @contentqueenmariah⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠!

Other than that, enjoy - chat next week 💕

ABOUT THE GUEST

Cara Chace is an author, speaker and independent marketing strategist helping women entrepreneurs build sustainable, anti-hustle businesses without trashing their nervous systems. Through her Ditch the Chaos podcast, Chaos Detox method, and her book, The Social Media Burnout Cure, she teaches women how to stop running on fumes.

PODCAST TRANSCRIPTION

Mariah: [00:00:00] This is episode 352, and we're talking all about anti-hustle marketing and social media burnout with Cara Chace. Welcome to the Content Queen podcast. I'm your host, Mariah, entrepreneur, storyteller, digital nomad, creator of Content Bootcamp, and founder of Content Queen, with over 10 years experience in marketing.

This podcast is here to help you create your ideal content marketing plan by blending strategy and storytelling. So, let's get into it. Hello, gang. All right. Top performing episodes are always about kind of this anti-social media vibe. I know we love/hate social media. This episode is gonna be really refreshing if you're one of those people that is like, "I just don't know how this is working for me.

I'm just not sure, and I don't know what to do as an alternative." So, let me introduce you to Cara Chace. She's an author, speaker, and independent marketing strategist helping women entrepreneurs build sustainable anti-hustle businesses without trashing their nervous systems. [00:01:00] Through her Ditch the Chaos podcast, Chaos Detox Method, and her book, The Social Media Burnout Cure, she teaches women how to stop running on fumes.

So, if this resonates with you, let's get stuck into this episode, 'cause I feel like there's a lot to learn. Amazing. Cara, welcome to the podcast. Thank you so much for coming on. Um, just before we get stuck into all the amazing things you're gonna share with us today, just tell us a little bit more about who you are and what you do.

Cara Chace: Yeah. So I am an author, speaker, and independent marketing strategist. So, what that means is that I do not sell people on, like, website redos and social media marketing management or SEO services or any of those things. I approach marketing like data, and I work with clients to help them determine what marketing is working for them and what they can just totally put aside so they can get back to doing the work [00:02:00] that they love.

So my book is The Social Media Burnout Cure, and it really is about that concept of, let's make the marketing that we do intentional instead of by default 

Mariah: Oh, I love that. You're speaking my language. Amazing. So before we get stuck into, yeah, the, your book and all the amazing things you have to share, how did you get into owning your own business, working for yourself, doing consulting?

Um, what is your business story? 

Cara Chace: Yeah. Oh my gosh, it's such a long story, and I have such a unique career path. So my very first career out of college is that I was a special agent for the federal government, and what that means is that I did criminal investigations, and I did that for 10 years. And so that's where a lot of my very data-driven, evidence-based, just-the-facts-ma'am, like facts are more important than FOMO feelings when it comes to business decisions, that's very much the perspective that I have and how my brain works.[00:03:00] 

And then after I left that career, I ended up becoming the social media manager for the band Megadeth and Dave Mustaine. And long story short, I was managing 13 million fans across 17 social media accounts. It was my very first job in social media marketing. It was the Wild West of social media. It was before Facebook even had ads.

Like, it was crazy. So I jumped in with both feet, and it was a lot of fun. I, I transitioned to a whole new career skill set on the job, and that lasted for a couple years. And when I left, I actually had a very short stint for six months at a social media agency in the city that I lived in, and that's when I realized that I didn't think I could work for anyone ever again.

Um, it was not a good fit. The whole agency life thing was not great for me. I had, um, our first child by that time, so I [00:04:00] was not interested in staying until 7:00 and playing ping pong in the break room and drinking craft beer like so many other people there were. I wanted to go home and be with my family.

So- I started my own business because I really felt that there was no other option for me as far as what would work for me and what I had decided was and wasn't okay for my life. So I created my own digital marketing agency at, uh, the very beginning of 2015, and I have been in business for myself ever since.

Mariah: Oh my God, I love that. I feel like, uh, being, you know, in the criminal investigation and then social media, would have seen a... You would know all the ins and outs of social media and how to find things. 

Cara Chace: Yeah. Yes, I am really good at research. I can tell you that. 

Mariah: I imagine. I love that. So as you mentioned, you have a book called The Social Media Burnout Cure.

Yes. And when you wrote that, what was currently happening with the clients you're working with or your own business that made you wanna write [00:05:00] about this topic? Because I see it a lot as well. I think we're all on this hamster wheel at some point in our business, so I'm keen to know what, what landed for you to go, "I need to talk about this more."

Cara Chace: Yeah. So it was actually my own personal experience, not only with my own business, but some health issues that I had come up personally. So I was kind of falling out of love with the content treadmill and doing it for clients and trying to do it for myself and just more, more, more. And a few years ago, I started having health issues, and I was diagnosed with chronic Lyme disease and mold toxicity and infections and all sorts of nasty stuff.

And it was really my body finally saying, like, "Enough." "We... You cannot continue to do all of the things you're doing and, um, you know, heal from all the things you have going on." So I, I took some time off of my business, and I detoxed all of [00:06:00] the yuckiness out of my body, which was amazing. It took three years for me to detox everything out of my body.

And the main symptom that I was having was that I would get histamine reactions in my mouth every time I ate something. So it didn't matter what I was eating, I would have, like, a raw mouth and blurred vision and, like, you know, snotty nose. I mean, it was not pleasant. It was not good. And I was getting a handle on those things.

So I've been in digital marketing and social media for a long time, so I've seen kind of the ebbs and flows and the threads, um, that have gone on with people, you know, jumping on new platforms or burning out or trends and, you know, all of the things. And just this last December, December of 2025, I took my usual two weeks off at the end of the year.

So I throw my phone in a drawer. I don't even schedule posts. I do not care. I just retreat from the world and everything online for two weeks and [00:07:00] spend that cozy time with my family and just relaxing and enjoying ourselves. And about halfway through that two weeks, I stopped having all my food reactions.

And I thought, "Oh, I'm healed. I'm good. I can have what I want to eat." Like, you know, yay me, gold star. And the Monday or the weekend before coming back to work in the new year, January 2026, I sat down to plan my content calendar for the year, and I started reacting to every single thing I ate It was wild.

It was like when you do an elimination diet, if you've ever tried to eliminate, like, gluten or dairy or anything like that, and the thing that is causing physical symptoms becomes really, really obvious when you've detoxed it and then you add it back. It was that experience. It was that level of clarity and being that obvious.

So I thought, "Okay, my nervous system is reacting to [00:08:00] being on social media and planning content and the business stuff that goes along with it that I've been doing for 10, over 10 years at this point. I can't un-know what I know, so what do I do with this?" And what I decided to do was every single time I had a thought or an observation or a perspective that I would normally have chopped up into captions or reels or carousels or whatever it was, even, you know, an email to my email list, I put it in a Google Doc, and my book wrote itself in three months.

So, the other side of this story is that I stopped posting to Instagram in January. I put out a couple stories every couple of weeks for links to things I was doing locally, because stories are seen more by your local people and circles and everything. And, but I didn't post anything to my feed. And I looked in March after not posting a single thing to my feed in three months, and not [00:09:00] only had my website traffic from Instagram to my webs- to my website stayed the same, but my engagement had gone up

So we call that a clue. 

Mariah: Mm-hmm. 

Cara Chace: That is if I'm not feeding the machine three times a day, three times a week, whatever the latest guru has told you you have to do to stay consistent and visible, and not only did it not make any difference in my metrics, but some of them went up, what it tells me is that maybe it's not what they're telling you it is.

Mariah: Hmm. 

Cara Chace: And maybe I don't need to be doing these things for my business to still have a business at the cost of my health and my wellbeing. 

Mariah: Hmm. 

Cara Chace: So, um, that is essentially what the book is about. Part one is my journey through all of this. Um, you know, as a Type A perfectionist, how [00:10:00] I was set up and wired throughout my childhood and early careers for people-pleasing and performance and hoop-jumping, which is exactly what social media platforms want you to do for them.

And then part two is how to take your time, energy, and attention back from these platforms. And like I said in the beginning, I, I'm not anti social media. It's I want you to make an intentional decision about what you're doing and know that it's gonna benefit your business instead of just doing it by default because somebody said you should.

Mariah: Yeah. And I think so, too, like, um, with social media, and I talk about this a lot, is what is the intent in which you're there? Like, I have different clients that need it for different reasons. Like, not... it's not always about, like, sales. It can be about reputation and communication. Mm-hmm. And when you know that, it's so much easier to show up in the way in which you show up without feeling like, as you said, you have to be on this performance, uh, hamster wheel of always trying to, like, please the algorithms.

It's more just like- Yeah ... "No, this is my, this is my house." [00:11:00] 

Cara Chace: Right, and that's one of the things I'm very clear about in my book is there is no one size fits all. 

Mariah: Mm. 

Cara Chace: And I can't tell you what to do for your business and your life, but here's all the decisions and insights and ways to look at it and questions to ask yourself so that you can arrive at those decisions for yourself and what makes sense for you and your business.

Mariah: Yeah, I love that, 'cause it's so true. As you're saying, online, there's, you know, post three times a day, post three times a week, do this, do that. Like, there's always, like, you should, you should, you should. And the one thing- Mm ... that, um, and I imagine you've seen this evolve over your journey in social media, was, like, these kinds of, like, vanity metrics of, like, how I got to X amount of followers in X amount of days, and you could do the same thing.

Actually, there was a, um, my partner's South American, and there's a woman in Colombia a couple years ago that ran a course on this. Mm. And when no one got those results, they all sued her. 

Cara Chace: My goodness, yeah, you gotta be really careful what you promise. Like, there's no way that I could tell anyone unless they were my [00:12:00] one-on-one client exactly what to do.

You could not write a book like that and know that everyone is gonna get out of it what they need to. Yeah. Or a course or whatever it is. 

Mariah: Yeah, that's right. No, it's, it's, it's a interesting place now because everything is so accessible, and we feel like... And it, it's a very now, now, now, you know, type of thing.

Like, we get so caught up- Yeah ... in those, um, those vanity metrics. So you talk about, um, y- you mention you have the, the KAOS detox method. Yes. And I'm curious to know a little bit more about this 'cause this sounds like, you know, I know there's lots of people who listen to my podcast, some of my most popular episodes are- How can I do marketing other than just social media?

You know, 'cause there is- Right ... like we're always looking for ways in which we can be a bit smarter with our marketing. And, um, so I love everything that you say, and I'm keen to know, yeah, what is this chaos detox method? 

Cara Chace: So a chaos detox is my signature course, and I actually came out with it before I wrote the book.

So it has a lot to do with boundaries [00:13:00] and things like external chaos, mental chaos, and calendar chaos. So those are the three pillars in that course. So calendar chaos is when there's things on your calendar that shouldn't you're, be. You're giving time to things that are not benefiting you or your business, whether that's personally or professionally.

Um, external chaos is the boundary pushers, the people that ask you to volunteer, the people who want to pick your brain over coffee, you know, all of that kind of stuff. And then the mental chaos i- is another way to say mental chatter. So there's so many open loops you're carrying around constantly in your head.

You see people saying, "You know, I have 72 tabs open in my brain." Um, so it's a way to deal with that as well. So at the end of the day, whether it's marketing, whether it's your time management and productivity, it's about laying everything out on the table and looking at what you actually need to be doing [00:14:00] to meet your personal and professional goals.

Because the only person that will stand up for your boundaries is you, right? You can have lots of people in your corner, um, a partner, kids, your mom, you know, whatever it is, um, but at the end of the day, you're the only one that's gonna be able to say, "I don't have time for that right now," or, "No, I'm not gonna take on that opportunity that's gonna benefit somebody else," or whatever it is.

So chaos detox is an evergreen weekly planning method to start your week making sure that you have your best priorities in there. I don't do time blocking because as a busy mom entrepreneur, I never found that worked for me. Uh, what I teach is theme day planning, so less context switching, doing like tasks together so you can go deep, um, and how to assess what's working and what isn't and [00:15:00] make tweaks over time.

And the biggest part of it is to learn how to do it yourself because life changes. Seasons evolve. You know, you said you travel full time, so your schedule's gonna look different depending on where you are and what you're doing. For someone like me, who has school-aged kids, I, I have to redo my plans every three months, depending on what's happening with school and vacations and whatever.

So it's not just about how to clear out the chaos and really only put what's necessary to meet your goals, it's also teaching you the life skill of how to tweak and assess and evolve. 

Mariah: Oh, I love that. Yeah, 'cause I, I, I, I love what you're saying about sort of like theme blocking. Calendar blocking has never, ever worked for me either, and I think it's like, yeah, how can I focus my attention?

I teach this with clients with their marketing, right? Like, you know, you can, you can do writing on one day or, you know, if you do any video, you can do it on one day as opposed to like, you know, one post tick, one post- Yeah ... 'cause it's like your brain just like gets so overloaded [00:16:00] with all the things that need to happen to your podcast or, you know, whatever that looks like in your marketing.

Yeah. Um, because yeah, the task switching is a big one. I, I, I find the, the time it takes to switch a task is 

Cara Chace: It's not just the time. It's the mental drain on your energy. Yeah. Like, you can feel your bandwidth and your battery and your brain just like waah, you know, when you're trying to context switch.

We're also a terrible judge of how long things will take us. 

Mariah: Yeah, time blindness. 

Cara Chace: So you're setting yourself up for failure, and if you're like me and a type A perfectionist, it's like, ugh, I can never get it. You know? It just, it's not good. Yeah. It doesn't make anybody feel good. 

Mariah: No, I, I totally get it.

Yeah, time blindness is my biggest weakness, especially when I've got like Pilates to get to. Oh yeah, that only takes 10 minutes, so I can leave. Yeah. 

Cara Chace: Nope. No. Doesn't happen. 

Mariah: I love that. And I think, too, you know, one of the points that you've made is especially when it comes to, say, you know, everyone's like, "Oh, you'd be so good on a podcast.

You should start a podcast," or, "You'd be... You [00:17:00] know, you could do this or you could do that," and you're like, "Yeah, cool, that all sounds really great," and then you go to do the thing and then you realize, you know, all the time and the energy it takes you. So when you're really clear on like what it is you need to do to get towards your specific business goals- Right

that's when you can go, "You know what? No. A podcast sounds great, but totally does not make sense to where I am at in my life right now." You know, all those things. 

Cara Chace: Yeah, and you know, don't forget that you're allowed to change your mind. So for example, um, I have a podcast that is not an interview podcast.

It is just me talking and teaching, um, and it's based off blogs that I have spent 10 years writing, so I have lots of content. And I was doing that every week. It was all great, and I realized with the book launch that happened this year, so launching a book, publishing, launching it, doing the whole thing, that was totally new for me, and any time you learn anything new it takes so much time, energy, and attention.

[00:18:00] And five years ago me, maybe even two years ago me, would've kept doing the podcast while I was launching the book and gotten burnt out and angry and, you know, just been totally drained and had things break and not done really well. And this year I said, you know what? I am very aware that I cannot do both well.

So I'm gonna pause my podcast temporarily so I can launch my book and give it the best of me, because that's what it deserves. Mm-hmm. And when I go back to my podcast after I've, you know, gotten over the hump with launching the book, um, then I can revisit that and how I wanna do it. So remembering not only what your bandwidth is and that it's okay to, like, put things down, but that it doesn't have to be forever.

You can change your mind. 

Mariah: Yeah, no, I love that, and I think it's important to have breaks from things too. It's like when you... So 'cause I travel full time, so our routine, like, we try to keep a good routine, but it can be, you [00:19:00] know, hit or miss. And we just traveled 4,000 kilometers in, like, a week. Yeah. And so obviously I didn't have time to do my, like, go to Pilates or do my journaling- Right

or whatever. And then, and then when you get back into it, you really appreciate it, right? Because you had that break. So I think there's also the power in having a break, um, and depending on how you are with consistency and, and how you are about getting back on the horse, so to speak. Right. Obviously, the first few weeks could be more challenging than others, but I think it's just being...

And one of the things that I've really, um, felt from you is just really about understanding yourself and knowing what works for you versus, you know, what someone else is telling you you could do, because I think that's- Yeah ... so important with business. And I, I remember early days, you know, even, like, teaching, like, I was doing a content strategy in Trello, and I'm like, "Yeah, but you don't have to use this.

This is just what I'm using 'cause this works for me." It's the same with anything you do in your business. People are gonna have cool, shiny things that they use that may not work for you, and I think that's totally okay. 

Cara Chace: That's one of the central themes in my book, is learning how to trust yourself again.[00:20:00] 

So, in the last 10-plus years of online marketing, and influencers, and gurus, and educators, and all of that, it's become very easy to think somebody else has the secret or the answer if you're not seeing the results, which, uh, you know, it doesn't happen overnight for most people. Mm-hmm. Um, and when you start...

You know, an easy example would be, uh, I, I really am an introvert even though I, I come across as extroverted to a lot of people. Um, so if I'm buying a course on how to have a cold DM reels strategy on Instagram, I'm gonna burn out on that within a couple weeks, and I will have wasted my money because the strategy that worked for somebody that's not me doesn't work for me.

Um, and being able to spot those things up front and knowing this might be a path for somebody else, but it's not for me, and that's [00:21:00] okay, is something I've had to come back around to. 

Mariah: Mm-hmm. 

Cara Chace: Um, so I, I've spent a lot of time on money, time and money on things that have not been good for me over the years, and it's purely from painful experience.

Mariah: Yeah. Yeah. And I think I, I, I like what you say, like accepting that that is okay as well. And it's the same with, you know, even, um, I find this with social media. You know, someone will say, "Oh, Facebook's dead." And then I've got, like, people that love Facebook and thrive on Facebook, and it's kinda like, "You do your thing," 'cause, like, that's- Right

working for you. And that's... I'm never gonna be that marketer that... And I imagine you're the same. It's like you have people that say, yeah, this... Like your Gary Vees. "This is dead. That's dead. Don't do this. Don't do that." But if a client comes to me with something that really lights them up and they feel really excited about it, I'm gonna find- Right

the way, and obviously looking at the data and the numbers, to make it work for them rather than- Right ... shutting them down, because then that's when you block their creative thinking, and their passion, and all those things by saying like, "Oh, no, you shouldn't do that." 

Cara Chace: [00:22:00] Yeah, and it's so nuanced with everybody because, uh, when I first started my digital marketing agency more than 10 years ago, I had the perspective of I don't care if you don't like Twitter.

If your clients are on Twitter, you need to be on Twitter. 

Mariah: Hmm. 

Cara Chace: And I've since changed my mind and changed my opinion because I have been through burnout, and I have been through what it feels like when something is just not right for you on every level. And so yes, your clients have to be wherever you're spending your time with marketing, content, whatever, but you also have to enjoy it or know how to outsource the parts you don't enjoy.

You have to have that combination for it to really work for you long term. 

Mariah: Absolutely. Yeah, I t- I, I say this a lot of times because there are people... A- and, and to be fair, I had a client that used to hate LinkedIn. Now it's her favorite channel. So she had- She, she just made ways in which it worked for her.

Um- Yeah ... but yeah, you know, and, and we can argue now that [00:23:00] audiences, unless they're super niche, are on a lot of multiple different channels, right? And, you know- Yeah ... TikTok is not just a child's app anymore, and all those beliefs that we've had for such a long time. Yeah. And I had a client that's in, uh, was, uh, in financial advising, and they're like, "Let's give TikTok a go."

And this was like two years ago, and everyone was like, "Why are you on that platform? It's like a child's app." And they get, like, all these inquiries, and it's like, uh, no, it's not. It's absolute- Right ... it's actually now, like, a place where lots of people get their news and, like, scroll when they feel bad about themselves, and then, you know, all of a sudden get all the answers to the world, which is crazy.

Um, I was talking- ... about the, the hold that TikTok has on me as a consumer compared to any other platform. I don't know what it is. I'm just like, I, I just love it. It's my guilty pleasure. They 

Cara Chace: know how to push all those little, like, buttons in your brain, in your lizard brain. Whoa. All the hormone dumping, all the everything.

They know exactly what they're doing. 

Mariah: Yeah, which is crazy 'cause you know the documentary The Social Dilemma, I watched that. Yeah. And I was like, "Oh, I don't really get that." And I think it was 'cause I was [00:24:00] doing my work on there, and obviously I just saw it as a work platform, until TikTok- Yeah ... come along, and like, ah, I get it now.

Cara Chace: Yeah. Yeah, it's so true. So one of the other things that I talk about in my book is how we've engineered all of the quiet and spaciousness out of our life, and how we've made the switch to producing our lives instead of living them, and how one of the things that I got back when I stopped posting to Instagram and started putting all of my thoughts into a Google Doc that became the book is that I got my presence back.

Mariah: Mm. 

Cara Chace: So it used to be if I was having a moment or experience or, like, look at that beautiful sunset or whatever it is, I would almost im- automatically start crafting a caption in my head. How was I gonna package this? You know, you see the jokes on LinkedIn about, like, what this experience taught me about leadership.

You know, like, it, [00:25:00] it, it was so intrusive in my experience of living and life And so, you know, being able to take my presence back to enjoy the moment and not think I had to create a caption or do B-roll or, you know, any of these things made those moments so much sweeter and more obvious to me. 

Mariah: Mm. Yeah, I love 

Cara Chace: that.

So, you know, there, there's this huge nuance and gray area between social media, marketing, which are two different things, using it for your business, and still making sure that you have autonomy over your time, energy, and attention. 

Mariah: Mm. Yeah, and it's such a fine line, right? You have to- 

Cara Chace: Yeah ... 

Mariah: you're always, like, crossing that and trying to battle with that.

And I think that's just the digital age that we live in. And now with AI and- Yeah ... all the things. Like, it's only just, you know, warming up, really. Right. Eh. 

Cara Chace: Well, and that's the whole point. It's like, it's so [00:26:00] easy to be swept along by all of this. Mm. And so if you want it to be different, you're gonna have to be intentional- Yeah

and pay attention. 

Mariah: I love that. I just wanna hijack this episode to tell you about something that is generally helping and changing the game for business owners that I work with. So if you're sitting there at 5:00 PM scrambling, not sure what to do, what to post, you are not alone, and I have in fact been there, along with many other businesses that I've worked with, getting to my laptop, throwing something together, pushing it out there, throwing spaghetti at the wall, and seeing what sticks.

Now, this is not strategy, and it really feels like survival. That is why I created Content Boot Camp. It is my signature program that takes you through the seven steps to create a really intentional and aligned content strategy for your business, one that is actually documented, is actually for you, and actually gets results.

So there's no more guessing, no more winging it, and no more content hamster wheel. By the end of your journey in Content Boot Camp, you'll have a clear [00:27:00] plan on what to post, where to post it, and why, plus the confidence to actually execute it. And you're not doing it alone, because I do live calls all the time, so you'll get access to me, I can help you with your strategy, and a community of other business owners that are doing the same thing.

You'll also get lifetime access, so if your business evolves and grows and changes, it will grow and evolve and change with you. So if you are ready to stop winging it and start being intentional with 

Cara Chace: your marketing, get a strategy behind you, head to contentqueenmoriah.com. Check out boot camp, Content Boot Camp.

I would love to see you there. 

Mariah: And one of the things that you talk about, which is, you know, always music to my ears, is the, the data and, and looking at what is actually, you know, working for us and, and how we can utilize this information. I mean, there's been countless stories of me working with clients who get obsessed with things like Instagram and all the things, and then we look at the numbers and maybe it's a completely evergreen channel that's working really well for them that they really enjoy and didn't realize they enjoyed it as much as they did because it wasn't that [00:28:00] constant need to impress people.

Right. So when it comes to, um- Looking at our numbers and what is actually working, how can people start if they've never, like, really thought about this or, or thought about, "Oh, maybe social media isn't my place." Um, how can we start being a bit more intentional with utilizing our data? 

Cara Chace: Yeah. So the first thing is to make sure you know where to find your data and information.

Google Analytics, um, all the apps have some sort of insights, those kinds of things. If you use a scheduler, that has its own inherent data and analytics, right? So just making sure you know where those are, but particularly for the back end of your website. Unless you're someone who's, like, a huge influencer with millions of followers and Instagram is actually paying you, right, that might be a different situation.

But for most of us, really what we want is to see how what we're doing translates to sales, [00:29:00] customers, metrics that are improving our business, conversations and relationships, opportunities, things like that. Um, brand awareness, yes, it has a place, but if you can't really conceptualize how brand awareness ties to benefiting your business, how are you gonna justify that time, energy, and attention when you're looking at your calendar and you're going, "I don't know when I'm gonna fit in this batch reels day for Instagram," right?

So know where to find your data and your analytics is first. And then we already touched on it a little bit. Be super, super clear about what you need out of these platforms, right? Because they know what they need from you. They need content so that they have more eyeballs scrolling past their advertisers, which for Meta, it's over 90% of their revenue is advertising.

Mariah: Mm. 

Cara Chace: So they don't get that revenue if they have less and less content and less and less eyeballs. So [00:30:00] they're very clear on what they need from you. You need to be very clear on, okay, if I'm gonna post Instagram reels, I need to see... Maybe it's not a certain number. Maybe it's a percentage increase in clicks through to your website or your profile or whatever you want.

Um, but knowing what you want that particular platform to do for you, and different platforms are useful for different things. I wouldn't expect the same thing out of Instagram as I do my email marketing, right? You, you've gotta have a handle on why you're using the marketing methods you're using and how you're gonna measure those results.

And one thing most people don't think of is they only look at month over month. And what I have found, because I used to specialize in Pinterest marketing, Pinterest is a seasonal platform, so you can't really measure- Uh, metrics and results month over [00:31:00] month you have to measure year over year for the same time period, because throughout the year it goes like that.

So, uh, um, maybe if things aren't going the way you want them to go when you're looking at month over month and comparison, uh, comparing, excuse me, um, maybe try looking at the same time period the year before and see if that was the same trend a year before. Because people are on vacation, or nobody's shopping during an election cycle, or, you know, whatever it is.

Um, just having that 10,000-foot view and being unemotional about it instead of FOMO and fear-based about it. 

Mariah: Mm, I love that, and that sort of, um, seasonality is really interesting. 'Cause yeah, of course we always go, "Oh, it's up from this month," and I tend to do that, so that's a really good point. Because yeah, it's, everything is so different and there's always like, you know, there can be something like horrific happens in the world and everyone's kind of paralyzed by that.

Or, you know, like if you think about it from like a PR perspective, you, you wouldn't [00:32:00] pitch a story during an election period or you wouldn't... So it's the same with your, with your marketing 'cause it is a, a form of PR, right? It's put- Yeah ... and if there's a, there's a, if it's a big n- news month, you know, it's very hard for you to go, "Oh, well it's down from last month."

Um, so that's really important. I love that. And I think too, like one of the biggest things for me with anyone I do work with is getting them in there. Because, as you said, like, there can be this emotional attachment and that holds value to me as a person if, um, you know, I have low engagement or I have this, I have that.

It's just a data point, right, to get you closer, and it's a story that it's telling you. And if you're just starting out, yeah, your numbers aren't gonna be super high and crazy, and maybe the followers are gonna be harder to get in the beginning. And I think also we forget how much things have changed in these platforms.

Like I'm seeing people now, you get delivered content without even having to follow someone, so maybe that's not the right metric as well. Yeah. So it's like- Right ... you know, there's all these things happening and these platforms evolve all the [00:33:00] time, and consumers evolve. 

Cara Chace: Right. And the other thing to remember is the algorithms work based on what they want from you.

So I saw this when video was becoming the big thing several years ago, and everybody's talking about, oh, video's it, video's it. Well, that's because Facebook and YouTube were fighting for video domination, right? So that's why if you posted a video on Facebook that was a link out to YouTube, they would suppress it.

You know, all of these things. So it's, it's remembering that these platforms need things from you, and they are, they are guiding you through the maze based on the metrics that they want to see, the content that they want to see, all of those things. And if you go into it eyes wide open like that, it does take some of that, like, ooh, this is all about me.

Well, maybe [00:34:00] Instagram just wanted something different from creators this week 

Mariah: Yeah. It's so true, right? And I think also it depends on, you know, w- who's making the loudest noise on these platforms to, you know, the, um, the algorithms, and to the head of Instagram and, you know, if they're making most of their money off influencers or they're, they're, they're favoring, you know, what influencers are delivering.

And I think we get so caught up in this, like we didn't start our businesses to become influencers, and yet here we are thinking about how could this become content or how could I- 

Cara Chace: Right ... 

Mariah: um, put this out there. And I think that's why, you know, creating that diversity is so important and looking at it from the lens of it's just business.

Like, this is just- Yes ... a business platform. And yeah, like people have fun with it as well and wanna create personal brands and create their legacy and share their inner knowings, and that's awesome too. 

Cara Chace: Right. 

Mariah: But I think also you're having that lens of like how is this helping me long term? 

Cara Chace: Right. Well, and I kinda have this automatic, like, rebellious nature.

Like as soon as you [00:35:00] tell me to do something I'm like, "Mm, no. Not gonna do that." Me 

Mariah: too. 

Cara Chace: So when I realized how thoroughly creating content had like colonized my brain and the way I thought, I was like, "Oh, absolutely not. No. I'm not doing this." Um, and so figuring out how to unravel all of that, and I cannot tell you the freedom that that feels like- 

Mariah: Mm

Cara Chace: when you just go back to experiencing your life instead of packaging it. 

Mariah: Mm. Yeah, definitely. It's so true, and it, it's def- it's a hamster wheel that is hard to, to get off. So with the people that thinking, 'Oh yeah, like I would like to cut back but I'm worried about losing momentum,' maybe consistency's really...

Like if I get off the consistency bandwagon I may never get back on. Um- Mm-hmm ... you know, you sort of mentioned you didn't see that loss of momentum, um, yourself. But- Mm-hmm ... what do you tell people that are kinda like, "All right. I would like to take a bit of a step back 'cause I can see it taking over, but- 

Cara Chace: Mm-hmm

Mariah: this, this, this, [00:36:00] this and this?" 

Cara Chace: Yeah. Yeah. So, um, have a plan, know you can change your mind, and know that you can give it some time to test it and tweak it. One of the frameworks that I talk about in my book is signposts, not stages. So a stage you have to perform on, you have to be on that content treadmill, all of those things.

You gotta feed the machine. A signpost tells you pretty much like a business card, "Here's who I am, here's what I do, here's some things about me, here's where to find me." So if you decide, let's just use an example, somebody is trying to do like five different social media platforms. They're totally inundated.

They wanna get off. They're burnt out. They don't have someone helping them with it. They're just over it. I would start by looking at all the data and analytics and picking the top two platforms that are giving me the best results And the other three I would set up as signposts, right? You don't have to make some big announcement if they're not working great for you anyway, [00:37:00] right?

You can just make sure everything's tightened up and buttoned up on your profile and people know exactly who you are and where to find you, and then concentrate on the other two that are working the best for you. And I think what you'll find is when you stop dividing your attention like that and you can really focus on...

And it doesn't have to be social media. Maybe it's just Instagram and email marketing, or maybe it's a YouTube channel and Pinterest or may- you know, whatever it is. You're going to have so much more creativity and spark with creating that content, knowing that you then don't have to repackage it and repurpose it and redo all the things for all these five, six, seven different platforms because they're evergreen and working like a business card.

Mariah: Yeah. 

Cara Chace: And then give it time to work, three months, six months. Take a deep breath and just let it happen, and then go back and look at your numbers And if you find what you expected, great. Keep doing what you're doing. If you found, well, [00:38:00] that didn't work, or I'd like to add this back in or whatever it is, you're allowed to change your mind and keep testing different things.

Mariah: Mm. 

Cara Chace: No one is going to fault y- no one is paying attention so completely that they're like, "Oh, Mariah didn't post on LinkedIn for three months, and, um, now she is again, and that's really weird." Like, nobody cares. Just, just keep doing what feels right for you, and testing and tweaking and re-evaluating. 

Mariah: Yeah.

I love that, and I think, uh, I, I had the same experience with... For some reason I thought Twitter was a good idea when I first started, and I, I was side hustling, so I was, like, trying to, like, do a tweet in my lunch break, and I'm like, "What am I doing? This is just, like, not making any difference." But I, I love the idea of, like, yes, now with Google indexing most social platforms and posts, you can...

Like, some things can work evergreen for you, even though it's like, social media, that doesn't make sense. But I love that. Right. I think that is, like, such great advice. I had a client that was [00:39:00] fighting Instagram for so long, and when she was like, "It's just LinkedIn. It's just LinkedIn. It's my blog. It's LinkedIn.

Let's just sto-" And like I said, like, "It's okay. We can, we can do that." Yeah. And now she's like, I... She's like, "Oh, my God," and she... We, we did it in stages. So first she went, "Let's cut back Instagram, and then I won't go in there, so you just go in there." And then she, and then she's like, "Okay, let's stop it." And now I feel like she's just got this, like, weight lifted off her shoulders, and I think she had to feel like, like I was gonna be disappointed if she stopped Instagram.

She was disappointed in herself because she'd been doing it for so long, and it's like, it's okay. Like- Yeah ... even if you did put all your energy into it for two years, three years, it, the content's still there. It's not going anywhere. Yeah. It can still gain views potentially. Like, it's still indexing- Right

in Google at some point. Like, I think we just get so, like, uh, it's cra- like, it sounds crazy to say out loud, right? But that's just how we're feeling inside, like we've failed in some way, which is, like, so not true. 

Cara Chace: Well, social media, you know, it started as personal for everyone, [00:40:00] right? And somewhere along the line, uh, you know, the likes started to matter, and you heard stories about kids who would delete their posts if they didn't get enough likes right away or hearts.

You know, all of that kind of stuff, and it pushed the buttons of being left out of your tribe. 

Mariah: Mm. 

Cara Chace: Of not being accepted by your people, of, of needing acceptance, all of those very fundamental human being parts of us. That's literally how the platforms work, and we've conflated it with business. So it's no wonder that it's all very tangled and messy, and we need somebody to help guide us through it.

Mariah: Yeah. Yeah, it's so interesting, and I, I do love that. I've been doing some work on, like, um, coaching people with, like, public speaking and being on video, and it's that belief that it ki- like, if you actually dig deeper into, like, why have I got FOMO that I'm not gonna be on this platform? And then you sort of, like, rationalize, you go, [00:41:00] "Oh, okay, that makes so much sense," it gives you that- Yeah

sort of permission to go, "Okay, I, I get it. I am safe. I can exit this platform and everything will be okay." Yes. And as you're saying, it does allow... Like, if you are on too many places and you're doing it all yourself, and then you're going, "Oh, well, email marketing's not working for me," and it's like, 'cause you're not giving it that full energy.

Not giving 

Cara Chace: it the attention, yeah. 

Mariah: That's right. Yeah, 'cause y- it's, it's going to scrolling on Instagram looking for a trending audio to do next week. 

Cara Chace: Yep. Yep. Well, they've... You know, they have completely obliterated any sort of friction to using these apps and these platforms. 

Mariah: Mm. 

Cara Chace: So what I personally do now, if it's helpful for any of your listeners, I actually use an app timer, um, and I allow myself 20 minutes a day across all my social media apps, and really what that ends up being is, um, sending reels back and forth to, like, my three friends, right?

Yeah. That's all I go in there for on my phone. Um, [00:42:00] and I actually have it blocked during my work time, so I can't get on those on my phone- Mm ... from, like, 8:00 to 2:00. And everything else on social media I treat as a work task that I do at my desk. 

Mariah: Love that. 

Cara Chace: So I am not trying to fit in work or fit in a caption or fit in this or that or, or whatever it is.

The, uh, totally checked out not work time that I have, it's 20 minutes a day, not during work hours, and everything else is work and it reminds me that this is something I'm doing for my business. 

Mariah: Yep. Yep, I need that. I need that, for sure. And I, and also I think now with, like, scheduling platforms and, you know, um, different, like say your Canvas and all that, you can actually get away with not picking up your phone 'cause I don't know if this happens to you, but I'll be like, "All right, I'll, I'll just, you know, um, search a sound for something or do something," and then it's, like, an hour and I've forgotten why I'm there.

Cara Chace: Yep. Yep, I like to look at it as, um, the opportunity [00:43:00] cost. 

Mariah: Yeah. 

Cara Chace: So the average person spends 1,000 hours a year scrolling social media. 

Mariah: Which, let that sink in. 

Cara Chace: What would you do with 1,000 hours back in your life? What's the life you're not living? What's the project you haven't done? What's the skill you haven't explored or the hobby?

Like, I took my 1,000 hours back and wrote a book. 

Mariah: Amazing. 

Cara Chace: Maybe next year I'll do something else. But what's the opportunity cost of not having those guardrails for yourself? 

Mariah: Mm. Ooh, I love that. I feel like we could end on that mic drop moment 'cause, yeah, it's, it's just reflection and not being hard on ourselves and just reevaluating how we're using these platforms, because there is a blurred line between this is for business and this is for pleasure, all the time.

Cara Chace: Absolutely. 

Mariah: Amazing. Yeah. Well, thank you so much for sharing all your wisdom, and I think it's come at a great time 'cause it's heading towards the end of the year. You know- Mm-hmm ... 2027, how are we gonna do things differently, how are we gonna be more intentional with our marketing, how are we gonna- Yeah

create a little bit more of this, like, anti-hustle marketing where we can [00:44:00] just live our lives, promote our businesses, and do- Yeah ... and, and also remember the reason why we started our businesses. A lot of us is for spending more time with family, travel, create a bit of a legacy. Like, whatever that looks like.

Right. That's the reason. Not to get 1,000, uh, followers or 2,000 or 10,000 followers on Instagram, right? So... 

Cara Chace: Bingo, you got it. 

Mariah: Amazing. So how can people find you, read your book, and learn more about, yeah, all the things that you've been learning on your journey from, you know, creating your own marketing agency and writing your own book and sort of, um, releasing the shackles of socials?

Cara Chace: Yeah, so everything's on my website. That's my hub, of course. So it's C-A-R-A-C-H-A-C-E.com, carachace.com. And my book is available anywhere online you buy books. So you can get it through my website, but, um, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, like Books-A-Million. Wherever you can buy books online, you can pick up my book.

Mariah: Amazing, and the perfect read just in time for the new year, so I highly recommend. I'm gonna, uh, that can be my, uh, [00:45:00] Christmas break book. 

Cara Chace: Yay. 

Mariah: Thank you- Perfect ... so much for joining. I really appreciate it. 

Cara Chace: Thank you for having me. 

Mariah: All right, what did you think? Key takeaways for me was really about understanding what works for you, what works for your business, and really understanding- Like getting that, working through that, and that takes time, and that can be seasons, right?

It doesn't mean that if you love social media now, you will love it forever, or there is a certain season in which you feel like marketing your business in a certain way really works for you. I have a client that I work with kind of seasonally because she works to different patterns in her business that not only work, but she will resonate with.

So for her, what she does is she plans her marketing calendar and work around energy, things that are working, things she wants to test, things she wants to try. So while there might be things that she's consistently doing, there's things that she's, like, in and out doing, right? And I think that's normal, and I think that's okay.

Of course, we're in this world where [00:46:00] consistency is really key and really important, but consistency in just marketing in general can be enough, right? So I'd love to know what resonated in this podcast, what you're gonna try in 2027. We're getting to the pointy end of the year, so a lot of the episodes coming out in the next few weeks to month will be really about what we're doing next year.

And you don't have to make any dramatic changes right now. You can sit on it. You can have some time off over Christmas, over New Year's, and see what you wanna do in 2027. That's also okay. But be a content queen or king and remember that developing your strategy and story develops your business. Thank you so much for joining me today, and please don't forget to share this with all your business and entrepreneurial friends.

You can do this by sharing it with them, share, sharing the link, adding it to your stories, and tagging us @contentqueenmariah, or just tell them about it. As I said, share them the link. If you do love these episodes, you love these guests, you love the value that we give, please leave a rate and review. It does help me get in the charts.

More people find the podcast, [00:47:00] which means more amazing guests for you. And if you follow me on Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, make sure you tell me what episodes you loved, what you wanna hear more about, who you wanna hear from, and I'll be planning next year's content very soon. Bye.